42 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 142 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 242 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 342 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 442 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 542 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 642 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 742 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 842 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 942 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 1042 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 1142 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 1242 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 1342 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 1442 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 1542 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 1642 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 1742 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 1842 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 1942 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 2042 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 2142 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 2242 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 2342 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 2442 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 2542 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 2642 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 2742 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 2842 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 2942 E Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY - Image 30

$1,235,000

3 Beds 2 Baths 1,778 SQFT 11.20 Acres
Type: Single Family

42 E Bartlett Road
Middle Island, NY 11953

MLS#: 1030942
Laurie A. Riechert
Laurie A. Riechert
Signature Premier Properties
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Phone: 516.448.8195
Office: 631.673.3700
Jonathan Riechert
Jonathan Riechert
Signature Premier Properties
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Phone: 516.458.0776
Office: 631.673.3700
Listing Brokerage: Signature Premier Properties | Listing #: 1030942 | Status: Active | Contact: 516.448.8195
Listings courtesy of Onekey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID.
IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use. It may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed by MLS GRID. Use of the MLS GRID Data may be subject to an end user license agreement prescribed by the applicable MLS, if any, and as amended from time to time. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 09/26/2026 03:42 AM. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.

Property Description

 

Welcome to 42 E Bartlett Road, a rare real estate opportunity in Middle Island, NY, combining two side-by-side parcels for a total of 11.20 acres of flat, tree-lined land. This unique package includes a 1.38-acre residential lot with the main home, connected to an expansive, private 9.82-acre lot. Surrounded by mature trees, the property offers excellent privacy and a spacious, park-like setting, giving you a quiet country feel while keeping you close to everyday amenities. The home is a classic, single-story ranch with 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, including a primary bedroom with an ensuite bath, all designed entirely on one level for easy daily living. Featuring two cozy fireplaces and an open layout, the house serves as a great blank canvas for your own updates, renovations, or future additions, and already boasts major recent upgrades including a new roof, new windows, a new oil burner, and a new septic system installed within the last two years. Properties with this much acreage are hard to find, and the large, level ground offers many possibilities, whether you want to set up agricultural or equestrian spaces, build a larger private compound, or look into future land subdivision. Located in the Longwood Central School District, this property provides a great balance of peace and convenience, with easy access to local parks, shopping, dining, and major roads. This property is located in a horse friendly neighborhood.


 

Interior Features

Bedrooms

Total Bedrooms3

Bathrooms

Half Baths0
Total Baths2

Kitchen

Eat-in KitchenY

Other Interior Features

General FeaturesFirst Floor Bedroom, First Floor Full Bath, Eat-in Kitchen
BasementUnfinished
Basement (Y/N)Yes
Basement FeaturesUnfinished
Fireplace FeaturesWood Burning
Fireplace Y/NYes
FlooringHardwood
Interior AmenitiesFirst Floor Bedroom, First Floor Full Bath, Eat-in Kitchen
Total Fireplaces2
Window FeaturesNew Windows

General

Additional Parcels Y/NYes
AppliancesDishwasher, Dryer, Electric Oven, Refrigerator, Oil Water Heater
Architectural StyleRanch
AttributionContact631-673-3700
Building Area Units0 sqft
Carport Y/NNo
CityBrookhaven
Construction MaterialsFrame
CoolingWall/Window Unit(s)
CountySuffolk County
Elementary SchoolWest Middle Island School
Elementary School DistrictLongwood
Full Baths2
Garage Spaces2
Garage Y/NYes
HOANo
HeatingBaseboard, Oil
High SchoolLongwood High School
High School DistrictLongwood
Listing AppliancesDishwasher, Dryer, Electric Oven, Refrigerator, Oil Water Heater
Middle/Junior High SchoolLongwood Junior High School
Middle/Junior School DistrictLongwood
Other StructuresBarn(s)
Parcel Number200
Patio/Porch FeaturesCovered, Porch
PostalCityMiddle Island
Property Attached Y/NYes
Property SubtypeSingle Family Residence
Property TypeResidential
Senior Community Y/NNo
SewerCesspool
Standard StatusActive
Tax Annual Amount$22,935
Tax Assessed Value$1,600
Tax Year2025
Total Rooms8
UtilitiesWater Connected
ViewLake, Trees/Woods
Waterfront FeaturesPond
Year Built1963

Exterior

Door FeaturesStorm Door(s)
Exterior AmenitiesAwning(s), Rain Gutters
General Features Ext.Awning(s), Rain Gutters
Horse Y/NYes
Parking FeaturesDriveway, Off Street
Parking FeaturesDriveway, Off Street
Water SourcePublic
Waterfront Y/NYes
Presented by: Signature Premier Properties

Additional Details

Price History

Schools 

Middle School Longwood Junior High School
Elementary School West Middle Island School
High School Longwood High School

  

Similar Properties

$1,235,000

3 Beds 2 Baths 1,778 SQFT 11.20 Acres
Type: Single Family

42 E Bartlett Road
Middle Island, NY 11953

MLS#: 1030942
Laurie A. Riechert
Laurie A. Riechert
Signature Premier Properties
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Phone: 516.448.8195
Office: 631.673.3700
Jonathan Riechert
Jonathan Riechert
Signature Premier Properties
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Phone: 516.458.0776
Office: 631.673.3700